Sunday, 09 July 2006
A history lesson
Contributed by Zero Ponsdorf

Keep in mind that battle at The Alamo and subsequent battles leading to Texas independence from Mexico were NOT part of the Mexican-American War, and using that category for reference captures an idea rather than a fact.

That said; I found this article of interest, maybe you will as well.

War on the Border
Lessons from the Mexican-American war.

Victory in the Mexican War meant that the country gained Texas, California, and everything in between, comprising most of what is now New Mexico, Arizona, Nevada, Utah, Colorado, and Wyoming. Next to the War of Independence and the Civil War, the Mexican War was the most important conflict laying the foundations of the United States as the power that it is today. Yet the war was controversial at the time, and the arguments and political maneuvering surrounding it still echo in debates over two of the most pressing issues today: immigration policy and presidential war powers.

Mexican textbooks claim that the American southwest was “stolen” and will someday be regained. Radical elements in the movement championing an “open border” between the U.S. and Mexico hope to someday fulfill this irredentist ambition. They see a mass movement of people overwhelming the “anglo” population of the border states.

...

Henry David Thoreau retreated to Walden Pond and wrote his essay on “Civil Disobedience.” James Russell Lowell mocked the soldiers as lower-class ruffians easily duped by appeals to patriotism.

Modern left-wing historians such as Paul Foos have followed Lowell’s lead, seeing an army recruited from a “despised labor force” and the war “critical in shaping the new exploitive social relations that would characterize ‘free labor’ and American capitalism in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.” The antiwar movement has changed little over the centuries, and its vision for the country has not improved.

Contributed by Zero Ponsdorf on July 9, 2006 at 03:26 PM in Remember the Alamo, Zero Ponsdorf | Permalink

Comments